General

Illegal contracts are those that involve actions deemed unlawful by statute, promote illegal purposes, or are against public policy. Such contracts are generally unenforceable, with varying consequences depending on their nature. Statutory illegality renders contracts wholly void and potentially criminal, while those void for public policy may be partially enforceable if the offending provisions can be severed.

Contracts requiring illegal acts or facilitating unlawful activities, such as committing crimes, defrauding tax authorities, or insuring against one’s own wrongdoing, are unenforceable. Courts refuse to aid parties benefiting from their own illegality and will not enforce agreements tainted with unlawful intent. For instance, agreements involving under-declared income for tax evasion are void.

Regulatory statutes often render non-compliant contracts void, especially when aimed at protecting the public. For example, unlicensed service providers cannot enforce contracts under laws ensuring public safety. However, minor regulatory breaches may not void a contract unless central to its purpose.

Modern legal approaches focus on the public policy underlying the relevant statute to determine enforceability. Courts consider factors such as whether the contract furthers prohibited activities, the statute’s wording, and the proportionality of voiding the contract to achieve legislative goals. This nuanced analysis balances statutory aims with fairness in individual cases.

Read a detailed Article on this subject with the Legislation and Cases, browse Irish Legal Guide  or Contact Us for advice below.